Abstract
Inter Partes Review (IPR), one of a set of administrative mechanisms used to review the validity of a patent after it has been granted, was once considered a key tool for patent litigators as an alternative to district court litigation. Beginning in early 2025, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) Director introduced a series of administrative rule changes involving “discretionary denial,” or the ability to deny institution of IPR proceedings. As a result, IPR has been rendered nearly unusable: the institution rate for an IPR petition has fallen from 68% in 2024 to 4% as of December 2025.
This Comment reviews the statutory basis for IPR in the America Invents Act (AIA) of 2011. It discusses why impeding IPR institution undermines congressional intent. Then, it explores the history of IPR discretionary denials, who gets to make the institution decision, and the criteria used to institute or deny, mapping out the tumultuous landscape of changes through January 2026. The flurry of administrative activity in 2025 that resulted in the extreme drop in IPR institution began with the rescission of the Vidal Memorandum in February 2025. The memo was replaced with new guidance that “bifurcated” the institution decision, moving power to the Director. New criteria were introduced, one of which focused on how long the patent had been in force rather than on its invalidity. And in October 2025, further changes resulted in the Director having unilateral power to deny institution of IPR, without the involvement of the Patent Trial and Appeals Board. Eventually, new federal regulations were proposed, which, if implemented, would cement the Director’s ability to issue unilateral, unexplained denials of IPR institution without consideration of the merits of IPR petitions.
This Comment proposes a new framework for discretionary denials which might serve as a compromise between the extreme policy swings of the past. This framework would allow the Patent Trial and Appeals Board to provide the initial determination of the IPR institution decision, while still giving the Director the ultimate determination of institution. In addition, the proposed framework offers criteria that provide strong precautions against duplicative IPR proceedings and inefficiency, while keeping the focus on patent validity and procedural certainty throughout the patent system. These criteria require parallel proceedings or serial petitions to be present for non-merits-based discretionary denial and take into consideration whether the parallel proceeding has been stayed, its median time-to-trial, and whether a Markman hearing has been held.
Recommended Citation
Elizabeth R. Ward,
Unplanned Obsolescence: The Dismantling of Inter Partes Review at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, and What to Do About It,
76
Emory L. J.
235
(2026).
Available at:
https://scholarlycommons.law.emory.edu/elj/vol76/iss1/5
