•  
  •  
 
Emory Law Journal

Abstract

Federal law enforcement agencies often make mistakes but rarely pay for them. The Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) is the main avenue for plaintiffs to sue the federal government for tort damages when wrongfully harmed. However, distinct procedural requirements in the FTCA limit the federal government’s liability. Notably, the FTCA’s “discretionary function exception” blocks claims arising from protected exercises of discretion by government officials, even when courts find that federal agents abused their discretion. Federal courts have struggled to apply this exception across government activity, particularly in claims against federal law enforcement—where the exception has morphed into a broad presumption that most conduct rationally related to public safety is protected from FTCA suit. With plaintiffs bearing the burden of overcoming this judicially created “police presumption,” the federal government frequently escapes liability altogether. This erodes the FTCA’s remedial purpose and conflicts with Congress’s expansion of FTCA liability for law enforcement conduct.

This Comment analyzes the growing conflict between Congress’s expansion of FTCA liability for law enforcement torts and the current discretionary function exception test. After first describing the FTCA’s structure and the development of its discretionary function analysis, this Comment identifies and analyzes the diverging approaches federal courts employ in assessing discretionary law enforcement conduct. The dominant approach leans heavily in the federal government’s favor.

To restore the FTCA as a vehicle for redress against federal law enforcement agencies, this Comment proposes a new test for discretionary law enforcement activity that accounts for the unique features of federal law enforcement. First, it argues that the federal government should bear the burden of proving the FTCA’s exception. Second, it proposes that the conduct of operational-level officials who lack policymaking authority should fall outside the discretionary function exception’s protection, thus opening more paths for FTCA claims against federal law enforcement agencies.

Included in

Law Commons

Share

COinS