Abstract
Over the past twenty-five years, society has come to understand the dangers PFAS pose to human health and the widespread pollution of these chemicals in the environment. As the federal government has been slow to regulate these “forever chemicals,” states and municipalities have begun to take decisive action by suing manufacturers and polluters. Minnesota was one of the first states to litigate when it sued local giant, 3M, for extensive PFAS pollution in the company’s own backyard across the eastern suburbs of the Twin Cities. The groundbreaking settlement between the state and 3M for $850 million was seen as a major victory for residents, who for years suffered mysteriously high rates of cancer, birth defects, and other illnesses. Since then, many states and cities have followed Minnesota’s lead and have subsequently sued—and settled with—3M and other chemical companies like DuPont and Chemours.
Nevertheless, Minnesota’s celebrated settlement is now revealing the limits of that approach. The $850 million is running out years ahead of schedule, drained by inflation, tightening federal standards, and construction costs no one could have accounted for in 2018. Now, as the settlement fund empties, the burden of continued cleanup slides back toward the residents the fund was meant to shield. The trouble is not the size of the settlement but its shape: A single fixed sum cannot answer a contamination that never breaks down. This Comment reads Minnesota as both a cautionary tale and a template, arguing that durable PFAS accountability can still be reached for Minnesota’s East Metro communities through renewed litigation to recover the costs now landing on ratepayers, and that states and municipalities litigating their own PFAS pollution need adaptive settlements that adjust over time and bind polluters for as long as their chemicals last.
Recommended Citation
Lauren M. Kramer,
Forever Chemicals, Short-Term Funds: Minnesota’s Costly PFAS Compromise,
76
Emory L. J.
131
(2026).
Available at:
https://scholarlycommons.law.emory.edu/elj/vol76/iss1/3
